Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Timing discrepancy in report of Egypt's 91st H5N1 case? - or error in the report?

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Timing discrepancy in report of Egypt's 91st H5N1 case? - or error in the report?

    ProMED just produced this, quoting SAIDR. Does anyone know what the story is with the red date? I have to assume that is simply an error (maybe a date from a previous case?). ProMED EAFR seems to think the patient was hospitalized on November 15 for an unrelated condition, then took ill with H5N1 on January 6, but how would she have contact with poultry while hospitalized for 52 days?

    Was one of the previous H5N1 cases hospitalized on November 15?



    Most Recent Alert
    View printable version
    Published Date
    2010-01-21 14:00:12
    Subject
    PRO/EAFR> Avian influenza, human (02): Egypt (Beni Suef) 91st case
    Archive Number
    20100121.205061
    Full Text
    AVIAN INFLUENZA, HUMAN (02): EGYPT (BENI SUEF) 91ST CASE
    ************************************************** ******
    Date: Wed 13 Jan 2010
    Source: Strengthening Avian Influenza Detection & Response (SAIDR) [edited]



    91st human case of avian influenza in Egypt
    -------------------------------------------
    A 20 year old woman began experiencing symptoms [of avian influenza
    (H5N1) virus infection] on 6 Jan 2010. She had been admitted to Beni
    Suef Chest Hospital on 15 Nov 2009. Her family reported she had
    contact with sick and dead poultry. She was reported to be in a
    stable condition on 13 Jan 2010. The MOH [Ministry of Health]
    reported that this was the 91st case of highly pathogenic avian
    influenza [H5N1 virus infection] in Egypt. Location: Beni Suef
    Governorate, Beba District.

    Source of report: Dr Amr Kandeel, undersecretary for preventative
    affairs, MOH, and Dr Samir Refaie, head of Epidemiology and
    Surveillance Unit, MOH.

    --
    Communicated by:
    ProMED-mail


    [The lapse of time between admission of the patient to hospital and
    the appearance of symptoms of avian influenza virus infection (about
    52 days) is unusual. It would be interesting to know when the
    diagnosis of avian influenza virus infection was confirmed and the
    precise reason for the patient's initial hospitalization.


    Beni Suef Governorate is located at number 5 in the map of the
    Governorates of Egypt, accessible at
    http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Governorates_of_Egypt. The
    HealthMap/ProMED-mail interactive map of Egypt is available at
    http://healthmap.org/r/012W. - Mod.CP]


    See Also

  • #2
    Re: Timing discrepancy in report of Egypt's 91st H5N1 case? - or error in the report?



    This is the original SAIDR report, containing the same dates. It appears that case #88 was admitted to a different hospital on November 15. Could that be causing the confusion?

    Comment


    • #3
      Re: Timing discrepancy in report of Egypt's 91st H5N1 case? - or error in the report?



      Hat-tip Commonground. This is the original Arabic report (post #1 of this thread). The admission date of this case is January 11, 2010, not November 15. November 15 is an error.

      I suspect ProMED EAFR will need to issue a correction.

      Comment

      Working...
      X