Tweet
AJIC
Impact of multiple consecutive donnings on filtering facepiece respirator fit
Michael S. Bergman, MS, Dennis J. Viscusi, BS, Ziqing Zhuang, PhD, Andrew J. Palmiero, MHS, Jeffrey B. Powell, MS, Ronald E. Shaffer, PhDemail address
published online 24 August 2011.
Background
A concern with reuse of National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health–certified N95 filtering facepiece respirators (FFRs) is that multiple donnings could stress FFR components, impairing fit. This study investigated the impact of multiple donnings on the facepiece fit of 6 N95 FFR models using a group of 10 experienced test subjects per model.
Methods
The TSI PORTACOUNT Plus and N95 Companion accessory were used for all tests. After qualifying by passing a standard Occupational Safety and Health Administration fit test, subjects performed up to 20 consecutive tests on an individual FFR sample using a modified protocol. Regression analyses were performed for the percentage of donnings resulting in fit factors (FFs) ≥100 for all 6 FFR models combined.
Results
Regression analyses showed statistical significance for donning groups 1-10, 1-15, and 1-20. The mean percentage of donnings with an FF ≥100 was 81%-93% for donning group 1-5, but dropped to 53%-75% for donning group 16-20.
Conclusions
Our results show that multiple donnings had a model-dependent impact on fit for the 6 N95 models evaluated. The data suggest that 5 consecutive donnings can be performed before FFs consistently drop below 100.
Impact of multiple consecutive donnings on filtering facepiece respirator fit
Michael S. Bergman, MS, Dennis J. Viscusi, BS, Ziqing Zhuang, PhD, Andrew J. Palmiero, MHS, Jeffrey B. Powell, MS, Ronald E. Shaffer, PhDemail address
published online 24 August 2011.
Background
A concern with reuse of National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health–certified N95 filtering facepiece respirators (FFRs) is that multiple donnings could stress FFR components, impairing fit. This study investigated the impact of multiple donnings on the facepiece fit of 6 N95 FFR models using a group of 10 experienced test subjects per model.
Methods
The TSI PORTACOUNT Plus and N95 Companion accessory were used for all tests. After qualifying by passing a standard Occupational Safety and Health Administration fit test, subjects performed up to 20 consecutive tests on an individual FFR sample using a modified protocol. Regression analyses were performed for the percentage of donnings resulting in fit factors (FFs) ≥100 for all 6 FFR models combined.
Results
Regression analyses showed statistical significance for donning groups 1-10, 1-15, and 1-20. The mean percentage of donnings with an FF ≥100 was 81%-93% for donning group 1-5, but dropped to 53%-75% for donning group 16-20.
Conclusions
Our results show that multiple donnings had a model-dependent impact on fit for the 6 N95 models evaluated. The data suggest that 5 consecutive donnings can be performed before FFs consistently drop below 100.
