CIDRAP Op-Ed: Measles didn't come back overnight; here are 5 things we need now
Jess Steier, DrPhToday at 9:34 a.m.
Measles
Childhood Vaccines
Anti-science
In the days since we first learned that the United States had lost its measles elimination status, I’ve read hundreds of takes on what that means. Many are full of frustration with current federal health leadership, much of it valid and much of which I share. Others point out that this didn’t just materialize in the past year, with some important caveats.
Both are true, and the way they intersect shapes what we need to do next.
It would be easy to say this all started in West Texas in January 2025, when an outbreak in a Mennonite community began and never truly stopped. Outbreaks in other states have since been genetically linked back to it, and this week, the Pan American Health Organization (PAHO) determined that the same measles lineage has circulated in the United States, uninterrupted, for at least 12 months, ending the elimination status we’d held since 2000.
West Texas was only the latest chapter of a much longer story, though. The conditions that let measles take root here built up slowly over decades, while too few people were paying attention.
Measles elimination took decades of work
The measles vaccine was licensed in 1963, and it took until 2000 for US health officials to declare elimination (PAHO verified elimination across the Americas in 2016). Getting there required more stringent school vaccine requirements and a second measles, mumps, and rubella (MMR) vaccine dose, recommended in 1989.That same year, a resurgence began that would sicken more than 55,000 people and kill 123 by 1991. The Vaccines for Children program followed, making vaccines free for eligible kids whose families might otherwise struggle to pay for them. Keeping elimination depended on all of those systems continuing to work.
Doubt about MMR goes back years
Two years before we declared elimination, Andrew Wakefield published a study of 12 children in The Lancet suggesting a link between the MMR and autism. The study was tiny and badly flawed, and investigators later found the data had been manipulated.Journalist Brian Deer also uncovered financial conflicts of interest that had never been disclosed. (Wakefield had been paid more than £400,000 by lawyers preparing to sue MMR manufacturers, and some of the children in the study were referred through those same lawyers. The year before the paper came out, he had also filed a patent involving an alternative measles vaccine.)
In 2007, Jenny McCarthy brought the autism claim to Oprah's couch and to millions of parents who had never heard of The Lancet. She wasn't a scientist, which was part of her appeal. She was a mom who said she'd seen it happen to her own son.
By the time The Lancet retracted the paper in 2010—unfortunately, 12 years after it was published—and Wakefield lost his medical license, the claim had spread far beyond him. Since then, studies of more than a million children have found no link between the MMR vaccine and autism, including among kids already at higher risk of autism.
At the same time, the vaccine's success made those claims easier to believe. A generation of parents were raising kids without ever seeing a case of measles or the damage it could cause firsthand, so the disease felt abstract, while claims about the vaccine felt personal. When public health works, people forget what it’s protecting them from.
Outbreaks in 2014 and 2019: early warnings signs
In 2014-2015, a Disneyland measles outbreak spread to several states. In 2019, outbreaks in New York nearly cost us our elimination status. Both were eventually contained, and both states responded, California by ending personal belief exemptions and New York by repealing its religious exemption.Elsewhere, exemptions crept up and coverage slipped in some communities, while social media carried doubt about vaccines to people who would never have read a medical journal.
Then COVID disrupted routine childhood visits, and trust in public health split along party lines. Kindergarten MMR coverage fell from 95.2% in 2019-2020 to 92.4% in 2025-2026. Not every unvaccinated child has a hesitant parent, though. Plenty of families run into logistical barriers such as transportation problems, clinician shortages, or jobs that don't allow time off for appointments.
Each year of declining coverage means another group of kids starts school without protection, and they stay unprotected as they move up through the grades. Unvaccinated kids also tend to cluster within communities, so national averages may hide pockets where coverage is far lower.
That shows up in who’s getting sick. School-aged kids and teens account for 40% of this year’s cases, and adults for another 41% (up from 29% last year). Nearly all were unvaccinated or had unknown vaccination status. Some of those adults never got both doses of MMR or lack an official record to show that they did.Each year of declining coverage means another group of kids starts school without protection.
Doubt about vaccines now comes straight from HHS
For decades, people spreading doubt about vaccines were working against our federal health agencies. Robert F. Kennedy Jr. spent years as one of the most prominent voices in that movement, leading Children’s Health Defense. In 2017, during a measles outbreak in Minnesota’s Somali community, where vaccination rates had fallen amid fears about autism, he wrote that “science and anecdotal evidence suggest that Africans and African Americans may be particularly vulnerable to vaccine injuries including autism.”In 2019, he traveled to Samoa after writing to the prime minister proposing that his team investigate the safety of the country’s MMR vaccines. Months later, a measles outbreak there killed 83 people, most of them children under 5 years, and public health experts in Samoa said people opposed to vaccines, some emboldened by his visit, hampered their response to the outbreak.
In 2021, Kennedy visited Lancaster County, Pennsylvania, where he made light of his own childhood case of measles and suggested that vaccines cause autism and autoimmune diseases. This year, Lancaster County was at the center of the outbreak that caused Pennsylvania’s first measles-associated deaths in 35 years, two infants too young to be vaccinated. It remains the epicenter of the largest state outbreak our nation has seen in decades.
Now Kennedy runs the Department of Health and Human Services (HHS). When measles hit Texas in early 2025, he cited the MMR vaccine as the most effective way to prevent measles while also promoting vitamin A and cod liver oil and describing vaccination as a personal choice. A few months later, he removed every member of the Advisory Committee on Immunization Practices (ACIP), which advises the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) on vaccines.
In January, HHS cut the number of diseases on the routine childhood schedule down to 11 without the usual scientific review, until a federal judge blocked the changes in March. In August, President Donald Trump signed an executive order calling for MMR to be split into three separate shots and suggested the combined vaccine could be “quite lethal,” then admitted he had no evidence for that claim. After Pennsylvania announced its first deaths, RFK Jr. suggested they “may even have been altogether fabricated,” and Reuters later reported that he directed the CDC to remove the deaths from its national count. Official CDC measles deaths (six) still lag the total reported by individual states (11, with eight in Pennsylvania).
RFK Jr. isn’t solely responsible for the declining immunization rates that have allowed measles outbreaks to take hold, but inheriting a public health problem doesn’t excuse how you respond to it. He is the person responsible for supporting and implementing the programs that close those gaps, and so far his department has sent mixed messages about MMR while weakening the committee that shapes vaccine recommendations and the agencies that respond to outbreaks.
People point out that kindergarten coverage barely moved during his first year, as if that settles it. That coverage reflects decisions families made starting when those kids were babies, so the effects of today’s decisions won’t show up for years, just as we’re only now seeing the effects of decisions made years ago.RFK Jr. isn’t solely responsible for the declining immunization rates that have allowed measles outbreaks to take hold, but inheriting a public health problem doesn’t excuse how you respond to it.
Why blaming parents won't help
It's tempting to blame the parents who hesitate or do not vaccinate, but I think that would be a mistake. Most are trying to protect their kids, based on what they hear from people they trust. Many have real questions about what's in the vaccine, what side effects look like, and how we know it's safe over the long term. Those questions unequivocally deserve patient and empathetic answers.I read a helpful piece in JAMA about evidence-based ways to have these conversations. Clinicians do better when they present the vaccine as the routine next step, then ask about specific concerns and acknowledge what’s driving them (like wanting what's safest for their child) rather than jumping straight into correcting a misconception. In one study of videotaped well-child visits, 74% agreed to vaccinate during the visit when the clinician presented vaccines as routine, compared with 4% when the clinician opened by asking what the parent wanted to do.
Blaming parents won't get a single child vaccinated, and it makes those conversations harder. Every time a parent feels judged, we lose ground in the much longer work of rebuilding trust.
What we need to do now
I'm not someone who likes to dwell on the past, and I'm not telling this history to assign blame. I'm telling it because what we do now will show up the same way, years from now, in our kids' classrooms and our hospitals.Other countries have found their way back. Venezuela and Brazil lost their elimination status in 2018 and 2019, respectively, and both earned it back by 2024. Canada, which also lost its status last year, has already interrupted the chain of transmission responsible for losing its elimination status in the first place.
To get ours back, we have to show that continuous measles transmission has been interrupted for at least 12 consecutive months, with surveillance strong enough to prove it. That clock doesn’t start until transmission actually stops, and countries in the Americas have historically needed more than two years after stopping an outbreak to regain their status. To get there and stay there, we need two-dose MMR coverage of at least 95% in every community, which will take at least five things:Other countries have found their way back.
- A clear, consistent message that the MMR vaccine is safe and effective. That should come from federal health leaders. Where it doesn't, medical societies, state health officials, and independent groups have to fill the gap, and many already are.
- Sustained funding for state and local health departments to run clinics, send out vaccine vans, offer hours that work for families who can’t take a day off, and reach the communities where coverage is lowest, in partnership with local leaders and in ways that fit each community’s culture and values.
- Trusted messengers in every community, including clinicians trained in evidence-based approaches to vaccine conversations, faith leaders, and parents willing to tell their neighbors why their family got vaccinated.
- Protecting school vaccine requirements. In states that fully repealed nonmedical exemptions, including California and New York, kindergarten MMR coverage rose 4 percentage points within three years compared with states that kept them. Several states are now moving in the other direction. If your state is debating this, contact your legislators and show up at hearings.
- Surveillance and data we can trust. That means finding cases, tracing contacts, sequencing the virus quickly, and reporting every case and death that states confirm. We can't prove transmission has stopped without it.
Dr. Steier is a public health scientist and scientific communicator. She is the founder of Unbiased Science, an organization that uses data visualizations, real-world analogies, and human voice to communicate complex scientific concepts for public understanding via multiple media modalities.
The opinions voiced in CIDRAP Op-Ed pieces are the authors' own and do not necessarily represent the official position of CIDRAP.